Who is responsible for fraud?

The ruling highlights that when determining the customer's gross negligence, the specific circumstances and the behavior expected from the victim, as prescribed by the law on payment services, must be taken into account. Therefore, simply approving a transaction by a customer is not enough to establish the customer's gross negligence.
This ruling clearly illustrates the expected future trend regarding responsibility, as the EU-wide PSD3&RTS regulations are expected to further increase the banks' liability in cases of fraud. In cases of impersonation fraud, where the fraudster poses as the bank or an employee, the financial institutions will bear the losses. Such cases not only result in financial losses for banks but also carry significant reputational risks.
The United Kingdom is at the forefront of addressing bank liability, with recent regulations stating that in certain cases, both the sending and receiving banks must jointly reimburse customers for losses from fraudulent transfers.
Currently, in Hungary, nearly 99% of the losses from fraudulent transfers are borne by the victims, which is exceptionally high even by European standards. In the European Union, this ratio is approximately 85%, while in the United Kingdom, it is just 30%, and this is expected to decrease further due to the new regulations. In terms of total amounts, fraudulent transfers in Hungary amount to 25 billion HUF, 800 billion HUF in the EU, and nearly 300 billion HUF in the United Kingdom annually.
If the referenced Supreme Court decision becomes standard, meaning that banks will increasingly be required to take responsibility for fraudulent transactions, it may be worthwhile for financial institutions to build even more robust defensive lines and focus even more on prevention rather than stepping in to bear the losses on behalf of the customer. In strengthening these defense lines, they can rely on us, as we are at the service of our clients.
You can read more about the Supreme Court's landmark ruling, which states that banks cannot be exempt from responsibility in cases of online fraud, here: https://jogaszvilag.hu/napi/peldatlan-dontest-hozott-a-kuria-a-vinted-ugyben-online-csalasnal-a-bank-sem-mentesulhet-a-felelosseg-alol/